What are Pre-Sentence Investigations?

Passion, Knowledge & Experience

When I was arrested and charged with two Misdemeanors, I was not only stunned but pretty scared too. I had never been arrested before and knew nothing of the process. Adam defended me with passion, non-judgment and thorough knowledge and experience of the law that I would have been utterly lost without. My record will be clean and I couldn't be happier. Myself, my family, friends and community are eternally grateful. THANK YOU, ADAM!! *****

Innocent and Facing Charges That Would Have Ruined My Life

"I had just recently graduated from law school and was awaiting my bar exam when I was charged with 3 class D felonies. Adam was incredibly invested and attentive from the beginning of my case. He greatly exceeded my expectations in how often he took the time to come visit me in jail with updates. He calmly talked my wife through the issues and helped her understand what was going on. Adam believed in me and took the case to jury trial in Monroe County Court. His courtroom performance was excellent, combined with a solid grasp of litigation procedures and law. The jury verdict was not guilty on the 3 counts. I WAS DISCHARGED AND ACQUITTED ON ALL COUNTS. Worst-case scenario I was looking at 21 years in prison, and instead today I have my life back."

Amazing lawyer

He is a very professional and well organized individual that will work with you not against you in any situation, and does his best to defend you and your rights in court. I would highly recommend P. Adam Militello for anyone in need of his services he provides. Avvo *****

What are Pre-Sentence Investigations?

There are two types of investigations that can happen before a person is sentenced to probation or a term of incarceration longer than 6 months:

1) a Pre-Plea Investigation; or
2) a Pre-Sentence Investigation.

These two investigations are actually the same thing, but they take place at different points on the timeline of the case, so they have different names.

A Pre-Plea Investigation typically takes place when either the prosecutor, defense attorney, or judge believe that there isn't enough information available on the case to reach or approve a plea deal. The investigation is performed by the Probation Department, and it is quite extensive. They run a criminal background check, interview the defendant, sometimes interview the defendant's family and close friends, they review medical and mental health histories, and look into the defendant's living arrangements. They detail their findings in a report that is often 10 pages long, and they make a sentence recommendation based on the charges.

These reports cannot be used against a defendant at trial, unless the defendant takes the stand and offers testimony that conflicts with what the defendant said during the investigation. In other words, as long as your story stays the same during the investigation and during your testimony at trial, you're okay. However, if you admit to wrongdoing during the investigation and then take the stand and declare your innocence, the prosecution is going to ask when you were lying... "during the investigation, or here in court?"

A Pre-Sentence Investigation takes place after a plea deal has been approved by the Court and taken by the defendant, especially if the sentence includes a term of probation or any sort of jail time. Typically, if the report comes back with some information that wasn't known prior to the defendant's acceptance of the plea, and if the judge changes his/her mind about a sentence promise as a result of the investigation, the defendant is allowed to withdraw their plea and either work out a new deal or go to trial.

In cases where Pre-Plea Investigations were performed prior to a plea, but a Pre-Sentence Investigation is required by statute because of the sentence, the Pre-Plea Investigation Report can be converted into, and accepted as, a Pre-Sentence Investigation Report.

For DWI defendants, these types of investigations are usually done when there is a plea offer involving probation, whether it's probation on a misdemeanor or on a felony.

An experienced criminal defense attorney can talk to you about how to conduct yourself in a Pre-Sentence Investigation. If you have questions, feel free to call me at (585) 485-0025.

The Militello Law firm
2480 Browncroft Boulevard
Rochester, New York 14625
Phone: (585) 485-0025 Fax: (585) 286-3128